| 
                      
                        
                          |   |  
                          | Philips
                                    - 1 LP - 802 806 - (p) 1968 |  
                          |  |  
                          | Philips
                                  - 4 CDs - 426 050-2 - (c) 1989 |  
 | 
                      
                        
                          | Ludwig van
                                Beethoven (1770-1827) | 
 | 
 | 
 |  
                          | 
 | 
 | 
 | 
 |  
                          | String
                                      Quartet No. 15 in A minor, Op. 132 | 
 | 47' 10" | 
 |  
                          | -
                                    Assai sostenuto - Allegro 
 | 10' 00" | 
 | 
 |  
                          | -
                                    Allegro ma non tanto | 8' 21" | 
 | 
 |  
                          | -
                                    Canzona di ringraziamento
                                      (Molto adagio) - Sentendo nuova
                                      forza (Andante) 
 | 19' 33" | 
 | 
 |  
                          | -
                                    Alla marcia, assai vivace -
                                      Più allegro - Presto 
 | 2' 20" | 
 | 
 |  
                          | -
                                    Allegro appassionato 
 | 6' 55" | 
 | 
 |  
                          | 
 | 
 | 
 | 
 |  
                      
                      
                        | QUARTETTO ITALIANO - Paolo Borciani, Elisa Pegreffi, violino
 - Piero Farulli,
                            viola
 - Franco Rossi, violoncello
 | 
 |  
 
 
                    
                      
                        
                          
                            
 
                              
                                
                                  | 
 | 
 | 
 |  
                                  | 
 | Luogo e data
                                        di registrazione | 
 | Théâtre
                                                    Vevey, Vevey (Svizzera)
                                              - 18-31
                                                agosto 1967 | 
 |  
                                  | 
 | Registrazione: live
                                        / studio | 
 | studio | 
 |  
                                  | 
 | Producer / Engineer | 
 | Vittorio
                                                Negri | Tony
                                                  Buczynski | 
 |  
                                  | 
 | Prima Edizione LP | 
 | Philips | 802
                                                806
                                                  | 1
                                            LP | (p) 1968 | 
 |  
                                  | 
 | Prima Edizione CD | 
 | Philips | 426 050-2
                                          | 4
                                          CDs - 63' 45" - 62' 00" - 42'
                                          22" - 47' 10" - (4*,
                                          1-5) | (c)
                                          1989 | ADD 
 | 
 |  
                                  | 
 | Note | 
 | - 
 | 
 |  
                                  | 
 | 
 | 
 |  
 
                              
 
                                  | 
                                      These was a time
                                              early in the century when
                                              an unfortunate mystique
                                              surrounded the last five
                                              of Beethoven's sixteen
                                              string quartets. They were
                                              regarded as the last
                                              terrible utterances of a
                                              musical superman which
                                              were somehow beyond mortal
                                              comprehension. Ordinary
                                              music lovers baffled by
                                              esoteric discussion of
                                              their spiritual
                                              significance hesitated to
                                              approach this holy ground
                                              and those who had the
                                              temerity to do so somehow
                                              guilty about finding
                                              enjoyment in them ar a
                                              first hearing.The
                                                last quartets are, in
                                                fact, completely
                                                approachable works 
                                                and to say this in no
                                                way detracts from their
                                                greatness - for
                                                greatness does not imply
                                                lack of enjoyment at the
                                                first hearing but rather
                                                increased enjoyment at
                                                the second. The real
                                                measure of these works
                                                is that no matter how
                                                  often they are heard,
                                                  they still have
                                                  something to offer the
                                                  listener.
 The
                                                    truth is that
                                                    Beethoven's
                                                    greatness lay in his
                                                    humanity and not in
                                                    some supposed
                                                    divinity; his last
                                                    quartets are all the
                                                    more meaningful if we regard
                                                      them for what they
                                                      are - great
                                                      testaments of
                                                      human experience
                                                      in which joy and
                                                      humour have their
                                                      place
                                                      with deeper
                                                      emotions.
 The
                                                        A Minor Quartet,
                                                        Op. 132 has a
                                                        good claim to
                                                        being the most
                                                        human of them
                                                        all. It was the
                                                        second (in order
                                                        of composition)
                                                        of a set of
                                                        three
                                                        commissioned by
                                                        the Russian
                                                        Prince Galitsin
                                                        in 1823 - a
                                                        commission which
                                                        encouraged
                                                        Beethoven to
                                                        devote himself
                                                          to the string
                                                          quartet form
                                                          again after a
                                                          gap of nearly
                                                          fourteen
                                                          years.
                                                          Illness,
                                                          however,
                                                          interrupted
                                                          the
                                                          composition in
                                                          1825 and in so
                                                          doing became
                                                          the central
                                                          feature of the
                                                          work. Over the
                                                          deeply felt
                                                          Adagio,
                                                          Beethoven
                                                          inscribed
                                                          "Hymn of
                                                          Gratitude of
                                                          one who has
                                                          recovered from
                                                          illness to the
                                                          Deity, in the
                                                          Lydian mode" -
                                                          the illness
                                                          being a
                                                          flare-up of
                                                          the stomach
                                                          and liver
                                                          troubles which
                                                          bothered him
                                                          chronically in
                                                          later life and
                                                          must have been
                                                          all the more
                                                          depressing in
                                                          the isolation
                                                          imposed by his
                                                          then total
                                                          deafness.
 Beethoven's
                                                          sketchbooks
                                                          show that the
                                                          basic material
                                                          and form of
                                                          the work
                                                          emerged from
                                                          wide study
                                                          which affected
                                                          many other
                                                          works of the
                                                          period. While
                                                          working on the
                                                          Missa
                                                          Solemnis,
                                                          for instance,
                                                          he became
                                                          engrossed in
                                                          the early
                                                          liturgical
                                                          music of the
                                                          Roman Catholic
                                                          Church and the
                                                          works of
                                                          Palestrina
                                                          which he found
                                                          in the library
                                                          of the
                                                          Austrian
                                                          Archduke
                                                          Rudolph, for
                                                          whom the work
                                                          was intended.
                                                          These
                                                          influences
                                                          became marked
                                                          in his later
                                                          works and
                                                          account for
                                                          the use of
                                                          what he calls
                                                          the Lydian
                                                          mode in this
                                                          quartet. (It
                                                          is actually
                                                          the Hypolydian
                                                          mode the scale
                                                          represented by
                                                          the white keys
                                                          of the piano
                                                          between F and
                                                          F.)
 The
                                                          sketchbooks
                                                          show, too, an
                                                          obsession with
                                                          the four top
                                                          notes of the
                                                          minor scale
                                                          and his
                                                          experiments
                                                          with their
                                                          intervals gave
                                                          rise to the
                                                          quartet's
                                                          four-note
                                                          opening as
                                                          well as the
                                                          fugue of the
                                                          G-Sharp Minor
                                                          Quartet, Op.
                                                          131 and the
                                                          Grosse Fugue
                                                          (originally
                                                          the finale of
                                                          the B-Flat
                                                          minor Quartet,
                                                          Op. 130).
                                                          There is also
                                                          some evidence
                                                          that the main
                                                          subject of
                                                          the A Minor's
                                                          finale was at
                                                          one point
                                                          considered for
                                                          the finale of
                                                          the Ninth
                                                          Symphony.
 At
                                                          the same time
                                                          Beethoven was
                                                          advancing his
                                                          own frontiers
                                                          of form even
                                                          further. Form
                                                          in the last
                                                          quartets, as
                                                          in the late
                                                          piano sonatas,
                                                          had become for
                                                          Beethoven a
                                                          flexible
                                                          channel whose
                                                          shape was
                                                          determined by
                                                          what
                                                          had to be
                                                          expressed
                                                          rather than
                                                          the rigid mold
                                                          of Haydn and
                                                          Mozart to
                                                          which the
                                                          content had to
                                                          conform.
                                                          The first
                                                          movement of
                                                          the A Minor
                                                          Quartet, for
                                                          instance, is
                                                          unique in its
                                                          structure and
                                                          the Adagio
                                                          is a
                                                          development of
                                                          the
                                                          double-variation
                                                          form also
                                                          employed in
                                                          the slow
                                                          movement of
                                                          the Ninth
                                                          Symphony.
 But
                                                          however
                                                          unusual the
                                                          forms of these
                                                          movements may
                                                          be, they are
                                                          quite as
                                                          clearcut and
                                                          straightforward
                                                          as the regular
                                                          forms (the
                                                          scherzo and
                                                          trio and the rondo)
                                                          which
                                                          Beethoven uses
                                                          in the quartet
                                                          when they suit
                                                          his artistic
                                                          purpose.
                                                          Certainly they
                                                          should not
                                                          discourage
                                                          anyone
                                                          approaching
                                                          the quartet
                                                          for the first
                                                          time. The fact
                                                          is that,
                                                          despite the
                                                          lenght of the
                                                          work and its
                                                          "peculiarities"
                                                          - and despite
                                                          the esoteric
                                                          theories of
                                                          music-metaphysicians
                                                          of earlier
                                                          days -
                                                          contemporary
                                                          accountes
                                                          prove that the
                                                          work was very
                                                          popular in
                                                          Beethoven's
                                                          lifetime. The
                                                          composer's
                                                          nephew
                                                          Karl, for
                                                          instance, was
                                                          present at the
                                                          first public
                                                          performance on
                                                          November 6,
                                                          1825. (The
                                                          work was first
                                                          heard
                                                          at a private
                                                          recital two
                                                          months
                                                          before.)
 "The
                                                          hall was
                                                          packed no
                                                          capacity,"
                                                          Karl wrote to
                                                          his uncle.
                                                          "It was too
                                                          full to hear
                                                          many of the
                                                          comments,
                                                          although I do
                                                          remember that
                                                          many of the
                                                          passages were
                                                          greeted with
                                                          cheers and
                                                          many members
                                                          of the
                                                          audience could
                                                          speak of
                                                          nothing else
                                                          than the
                                                          beauty of the
                                                          new quartet
                                                          after the
                                                          concert was
                                                          over.
                                                          Schuppanzigh
                                                          wishes to play
                                                          it again in a
                                                          fortnight's
                                                          time."
 If
                                                          the Viennese
                                                          public could
                                                          show such
                                                          unabashed
                                                          pleasure in
                                                          hearing the
                                                          work for the
                                                          first time,
                                                          there seems
                                                          little reason
                                                          why we should
                                                          feel guilry
                                                          about enjoying
                                                          our first
                                                          encounter with
                                                          it, or about
                                                          looking
                                                          forward to the
                                                          even deeper
                                                          pleasures that
                                                          growing
                                                          familiarity
                                                          with this
                                                          musical
                                                          masterpiece can
                                                          bring.
 
 First
                                                          Movement
 This
                                                          is sometimes
                                                          described as a
                                                          movement with
                                                          three
                                                          expositions
                                                          but, far from
                                                          it being
                                                          adaptation of
                                                          sonata form,
                                                          it has a quite
                                                          definite
                                                          structure of
                                                          its own. It
                                                          opens with
                                                          four notes on
                                                          the cello
                                                          which are used
                                                          immediately to
                                                          build up what
                                                          seems like an
                                                          introduction
                                                          to the first
                                                          theme. They
                                                          are, however,
                                                          thematic
                                                          themselves and
                                                          provide the
                                                          unifying
                                                          element of the
                                                          whole
                                                          movement. When
                                                          the first
                                                          theme appears
                                                          after a sudden
                                                          solo scamper
                                                          by the first
                                                          violin, they
                                                          form the basis
                                                          of the
                                                          accompaniment
                                                          and thereafter
                                                          continue to
                                                          give the music
                                                          the appearance
                                                          of breathing
                                                          slowly and
                                                          steadily even
                                                          beneath
                                                          violent
                                                          activity.
 Beethoven
                                                          continues with
                                                          a natural
                                                          development of
                                                          his first
                                                          theme, moving
                                                          to F major
                                                          (instead of
                                                          the expected
                                                          dominant of
                                                          sonata form)
                                                          for the
                                                          transition to
                                                          the second
                                                          theme. It is a
                                                          lyrical
                                                          flowing melody
                                                          shared by the
                                                          violins
                                                          against a
                                                          rippling
                                                          triplat
                                                          accompaniment
                                                          which
                                                          disguises the
                                                          fact that the
                                                          melody's
                                                          ehythm is
                                                          derived from
                                                          the first
                                                          theme and that
                                                          the harmony is
                                                          based on the
                                                          opening
                                                          build-up of
                                                          the four key
                                                          notes.
 What
                                                          would
                                                          correspond to
                                                          the
                                                          development
                                                          section in
                                                          sonata form
                                                          begins with
                                                          the key notes
                                                          in canon on
                                                          cello and
                                                          viola. After
                                                          their brief
                                                          development in
                                                          conjunction
                                                          with the first
                                                          theme,
                                                          Beethoven
                                                          moves now to
                                                          the dominant
                                                          of E minor,
                                                          with the key
                                                          notes in a
                                                          forceful
                                                          unison, and
                                                          proceeds to
                                                          restate his
                                                          material in a
                                                          revised
                                                          version (the
                                                          second theme
                                                          being in C
                                                          major). We
                                                          emerge in a
                                                          questioning
                                                          passage with
                                                          the four
                                                          instruments
                                                          hesitating
                                                          together
                                                          on the key
                                                          notes before
                                                          moving into
                                                          another
                                                          developed
                                                          version of the
                                                          first theme in
                                                          the home key
                                                          of A minor;
                                                          shortened
                                                          versions of
                                                          the transition
                                                          and the second
                                                          theme in turn
                                                          (the second
                                                          this time in
                                                          C, the
                                                          relative major).
                                                          The long coda
                                                          is built on
                                                          the key notes
                                                          and features
                                                          of both
                                                          themes.
 Second
                                                          Movement
 In
                                                          comparison
                                                          nothing could
                                                          be more
                                                          straightforward
                                                          in form than
                                                          the nest
                                                          movement in A
                                                          major, which
                                                          is a scherzo
                                                          and trio. It
                                                          is not,
                                                          however, the
                                                          kind of bold,
                                                          boisterous
                                                          scherzo
                                                          normally
                                                          associated
                                                          with
                                                          Beethoven: the
                                                          music has a
                                                          strangely
                                                          subdued,
                                                          almost weary
                                                          air about it.
                                                          The scherzo
                                                          theme is built
                                                          the same way
                                                          as the
                                                          previous
                                                          movement's
                                                          main theme -
                                                          an opening
                                                          three-note
                                                          motif played
                                                          in unison is
                                                          used by the
                                                          second violin
                                                          as the solo
                                                          accompaniment
                                                          to the
                                                          "melody" which
                                                          amounts to
                                                          only one short
                                                          falling figure
                                                          on the first
                                                          violin. The
                                                          fact that the
                                                          whole scherzo
                                                          is based on
                                                          these two
                                                          simple
                                                          elements gives
                                                          it an
                                                          inescapable
                                                          air of
                                                          austerity. The
                                                          trio, a mustte
                                                          in A major, is
                                                          much lighter
                                                          in texture but
                                                          thebagpipe
                                                          drone
                                                          characteristic
                                                          of this dance
                                                          and lack of
                                                          key contrast
                                                          perpetuates
                                                          initially at
                                                          least, the
                                                          slightly
                                                          depressed air.
 Third
                                                          Movement
 The
                                                          heart of the
                                                          work is the
                                                          Molto adagio,
                                                          the "hymn of
                                                          Gratutude" in
                                                          the Hypolydian
                                                          mode (see
                                                          introduction).
                                                          The hymn is
                                                          presented in
                                                          five short
                                                          sections and
                                                          is yet again
                                                          dual in
                                                          character for
                                                          each section
                                                          is proceded by
                                                          a short
                                                          prelude which
                                                          later assumes
                                                          an independent
                                                          thematic role.
                                                          Beethoven then
                                                          presents a
                                                          new, more vigorous
                                                          theme in D (Andante)
                                                          which he marks
                                                          "Feeling new
                                                          power" -
                                                          obviously
                                                          symbolising
                                                          the regaining
                                                          of strenght
                                                          after his
                                                          illness. The
                                                          hymn then
                                                          returns on
                                                          the first
                                                          violin, the
                                                          preludial
                                                          sections being
                                                          developed into
                                                          a continuous
                                                          polyphonic
                                                          accompaniment
                                                          in the other
                                                          parts (the
                                                          cello
                                                          retaining the
                                                          octave leaps
                                                          from its
                                                          accompaniment
                                                          of the second
                                                          theme). The
                                                          second theme
                                                          is then
                                                          recalled for
                                                          similar
                                                          variation
                                                          treatment.
                                                          Finally this wonderfully
                                                          conceived
                                                          movement ends
                                                          with further
                                                          variation of
                                                          the preludial
                                                          music, the
                                                          hymn being
                                                          ever present
                                                          like a cantus
                                                          firmus but
                                                          moving all the
                                                          while
                                                          from one
                                                          instrument to
                                                          another.
 Fourth
                                                          Movement
 In
                                                          complete
                                                          contrast is
                                                          the simple,
                                                          rather forlorn
                                                          little march
                                                          in A major
                                                          which follows.
                                                          It is in two
                                                          short
                                                          sections, each
                                                          repeated, but
                                                          even so hardly
                                                          merits the
                                                          title
                                                          "Movement",
                                                          Beethoven,
                                                          indeed, seems
                                                          to reproach
                                                          himself for
                                                          it, breaking
                                                          off into a
                                                          passionate
                                                          "recitative"
                                                          which carries
                                                          us into the
                                                          finale without
                                                          a break.
 Fifth
                                                          Movement
 The
                                                          finale is in a
                                                          simple rondo
                                                          form
                                                          (ABACABA), the
                                                          main recurring
                                                          theme (A)
                                                          being a
                                                          yearning waltz
                                                          stated
                                                          initially the
                                                          first violin
                                                          against a
                                                          restless
                                                          accompaniment.
                                                          Beethoven
                                                          moves to G
                                                          major for the
                                                          first episode
                                                          (B), which
                                                          opens with the
                                                          first violin
                                                          trilling in a
                                                          series of
                                                          descending
                                                          phrases
                                                          against an
                                                          accompaniment
                                                          derived from
                                                          the preceding
                                                          section. After
                                                          the return of
                                                          A, episode C
                                                          (in fact
                                                          developed from
                                                          the material
                                                          of A and B)
                                                          carries the
                                                          music to an
                                                          emotional
                                                          climax full of
                                                          biting
                                                          sforzandos.
                                                          Instead of
                                                          introducing a
                                                          third new
                                                          episode
                                                          Beethoven then
                                                          recalls a new
                                                          version of B
                                                          after which
                                                          yje main theme
                                                          makes its
                                                          final official
                                                          appearance in
                                                          an agitated presto.
                                                          We then move
                                                          into A major
                                                          for the long
                                                          coda based on
                                                          the material
                                                          of thema and
                                                          episodes
                                                          alike.
 |  
                                  | 
 |  
 |